During conciliation proceedings before the Micro and Small Enterprises Facilitation Council (MSEFC), the Council hears both the Supplier and the Buyer and explore the possibility of an amicable settlement. At this stage, the Buyer may consider making a settlement offer, admitting certain facts or discussing the possibility of resolving the dispute. However, Buyers often hesitate to do so because of one important concern: What happens if the parties fail to reach a settlement and the matter proceeds to arbitration before the same MSEFC?
The concern is that anything said, admitted, or proposed by the Buyer during conciliation might influence the MSEFC when it subsequently acts as an arbitrator. Although Section 81 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 expressly provides that parties cannot rely upon or introduce as evidence in subsequent arbitral or judicial proceedings any views expressed, suggestions made, admissions made, or proposals made by the other party during conciliation, the Buyer may still be concerned about the possibility of bias or prejudice, particularly when the same MSEFC conducts both proceedings.
Section 18(3) of the Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises Development Act, 2006 (MSMED Act) provides that where conciliation fails and no settlement is reached between the parties, the MSEFC may either take up the dispute itself for arbitration or refer it to any institution or centre providing alternate dispute resolution (ADR) services. Once the matter proceeds to arbitration, the provisions of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 become applicable. On the other hand, Section 80(a) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 provides that a conciliator shall not act as an arbitrator in any arbitral proceedings relating to a dispute that was the subject matter of conciliation. At first glance, this provision appears to prevent the same conciliator from subsequently acting as an arbitrator in the same dispute. However, Section 24 of the MSMED Act gives an overriding effect to the provisions of Sections 15 to 23 of the MSMED Act. This has led to the question of whether Section 18(3) of the MSMED Act overrides Section 80(a) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 and permits the MSEFC to act as an arbitrator even after conducting conciliation in the same dispute.
This issue has come up before several High Courts in India, where Buyers have challenged the power of the MSEFC to act as an arbitrator in a dispute in which it had already acted as a conciliator. Different High Courts have taken different views on this question. The Hon’ble Madras High Court, Allahabad High Court, Madhya Pradesh High Court and Chhattisgarh High Court, have upheld the statutory mechanism under the MSMED Act and recognised the power of the MSEFC to act as an arbitrator after conducting conciliation in the same matter. The Hon’ble Allahabad High Court also differentiated between an individual conciliator and the MSEFC as a multi-member statutory body. It observed that the concern of personal bias under Section 80 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 may operate differently in the case of a multi-member Council, particularly because the members constituting the Council may change between the conciliation and arbitration stages. On the other hand, the Hon’ble Bombay High Court, along with the Patna High Court and Karnataka High Court, adopted a different approach. These courts favoured a harmonious interpretation of the two Acts and held that although the MSEFC has the power to conduct conciliation as well as arbitration, it cannot perform both functions in the same dispute. Accordingly, where the MSEFC has already acted as a conciliator, it should refer the dispute to an independent institution or centre for arbitration instead of conducting the arbitration itself.
The matter subsequently reached the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in Gujarat State Civil Supplies Corporation Ltd. vs. Mahakali Foods Pvt. Ltd. (Unit 2) (2023) 6 SCC 401, wherein, the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India reversed the view taken in Gujarat State Petronet Ltd. vs. MSEFC 2018 SCC OnLine Bom 2039 and upheld the overriding effect of the MSMED Act. It recognised that the MSEFC can itself take up a dispute for arbitration under Section 18(3), notwithstanding the provisions of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.
However, an important question still remains unanswered. In the subsequent matter of M/s Tamil Nadu Cements Corporation Ltd. vs. MSEFC 2025 INSC 91, the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India considered a more specific question: whether the very same members of the MSEFC who had conducted conciliation proceedings could also act as arbitrators in the same dispute. This was a more focused question than the general issue of whether the MSEFC, as a statutory body, has the power to act as both conciliator and arbitrator. The Hon’ble Supreme Court of India referred this question to a larger Bench of five Judges for consideration. The Registry was directed to place the matter before the Chief Justice of India for appropriate directions and the matter is still pending. Therefore, while the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India has already recognised the power of the MSEFC to act as an arbitrator after conducting conciliation, the specific question of whether the same members who participated in conciliation can subsequently constitute the arbitral tribunal remains pending consideration before a five-Judge Bench. This distinction is important for Buyers participating in MSME conciliation proceedings, particularly when they are considering making settlement offers, discussing the merits of their defence, or making admissions during conciliation.